Skip to main content

No Value in European Bonds

Five years ago, ECB President Mario Draghi promised to do "whatever it takes" to save the Euro. In the midst of a sovereign debt crisis that roiled global financial markets, ECB action lived up to the rhetoric. Fueled by an extensive quantitative easing program, European bond prices surged and yields plunged into negative territory. However, in 2017 European growth and inflation finally started to accelerate higher, after years of anemic economic activity.

In an era of uncomfortably high financial asset valuations - European bonds take the cake. Trillions of EUR denominated bonds trade at negative yields - investors pay borrowers to lend them money. These negative yielding bonds are not just government bonds but the debt obligations of corporations too. A few weeks ago, Veolia - a BBB rated water and waste treatment provider issued a 500mm EUR 3 year senior unsecured zero coupon bond priced to yield a negative interest rate at issuance! The European junk bond index yields less than the 10 year US Treasury. Ditto for sovereign 10 year debt in Italy and Spain.

ECB QE inserted a price inelastic structural buyer into European fixed income markets ranging from sovereign debt to corporate bonds. Money managers were able to front run the ECB, driving yields on corporate bonds into negative territory in anticipation prices would continue to increase and yields continue to drop. Despite this capital dislocation, the ECB is likely pleased with the results. Credit growth has strengthened across Europe, unemployment is trending down, GDP and inflation is accelerating in a broad based recovery. Economists expect 10% growth of European capital expenditures in 2018. Given diminishing spare capacity, further inflationary pressure is all the more likely. The EUR strengthened against the USD from 1.03 to 1.20 in 2017, which could weigh on growth as European products become more expensive relative to the rest of the world. However, the European current account surplus recently reached record levels at 4% GDP. Currency strength threatening the recovery is a mitigated concern. The yield spread between German bunds and US Treasuries remains at historic wides. As US growth and inflation prospects tick up across the Atlantic, rising US Treasury yields should propel German bund yields higher and cause the spread to narrow. Political risk may rear its ugly head in March should a euroskeptic party win a mandate in the Italian general elections. Should these drivers persist, European bond yields must rise in tandem - with little or no coupon income to protect investors. Given positive economic developments and hawkish rhetoric in recent meetings, the ECB may end QE purchases in September 2018. Net European bond supply is forecasted to be around +100B EUR this year, which should pressure yields higher as well. A 50 bp sell off in the 10 year German bund would mean a 100% increase in yield. Once this structural buyer of the ECB is removed - there is no good reason to hold European fixed income exposure if you have the choice.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Concerning Observations from the Bond Market

"If something cannot go on forever, it will stop" - Herbert Stein Ten years ago this August, the French bank BNP Paribas froze three funds exposed to US subprime mortgages, an event many consider to be the beginning of the financial crisis. In "celebration" of the 10 year anniversary, I wanted to share some concerning observations from global fixed income markets: Since the beginning of the year, the yield curve has flattened  The 2s10s treasury spread went from 125 bps to 87 bps today The Fed dot plot implies 1 more 25 bp rate hike in 2017, and 3 more 25 bp rate hikes in 2018  That makes 100 bps over the next 16 months, the long end better go up.... Flattening yield curves usually precede recessions Global Debt is a 325% of GDP Corporate Debt levels are 30% higher today than in 2008 Corporate Debt to GDP is at its highest point in history NACM (National Association of Credit Management) have cited deteriorating credit conditions since 2014 The IMF re...

The Death of Risk

In 2019 the Federal Reserve cut interest rates in an effort to stimulate the economy. But it didn't need shoring up. The Fed described it as an "insurance cut." “Members who voted for the policy action sought to better position the overall stance of policy to help counter the effects on the outlook of weak global growth and trade policy uncertainty, insure against any further downside risks from those sources, and promote a faster return of inflation” to the 2% target, according to  minutes  of the July 30-31 Federal Open Market Committee meeting, released Wednesday in Washington. - Bloomberg The Fed has a dual mandate of employment and price stability. Employment has been below 5% for years and inflation has been hovering just at or below the Fed's 2% target for even longer. The S&P 500 has returned 15% annually for the last decade. The business sector is recording record profits. Why did we need any insurance?  Because the stock market went down. A l...

Internal Divisions: The Communist Party's Challenge in China

In honor of the upcoming 19th National Congress of the Communist Party of China, I will highlight some of the significant hurdles the Communist Party faces that often go under appreciated in the western media. Like in many states - the largest risks to government rule are not external threats, but festering internal divisions. The challenges range from the financial system to geography and regional inequality. What is largely missed in the endless discussion over the global financial crisis and its aftermath, is that it was Chinese credit expansion that fueled the global economic recovery. In the face of a cratering global financial system, and the devastation to aggregate demand that would ensue, China unleashed fiscal stimulus - especially in its housing sector. Commodities prices and emerging markets soared in the years after the crisis, providing ballast for the world. In the exuberance, many industrial sectors became plagued with overcapacity, a problem China and the world must ...